Thursday, 20 November 2008  
Who is responsible for the deaths of 353 asylum-seekers?
Zahra (6), Fatima (7) and Eman (9) - the daughters of Sondos Ismail and Ahmed Alzalimi -  three of the 146 children who lost their lives when the vessel that has become known as SIEVX foundered in international waters en route to Christmas Island on 19 October 2001.
  HOME
  ABOUT THIS SITE
  CHRONOLOGY
  FAQ
  READING GUIDE
  ARTICLES
   SIEVX Comment
   The Disaster
   Challenging
   Defending
   Abu Quassey
   Khaleed Daoed
   People Smuggling
   Not the First
   Two Brothers
  TESTIMONY
   CMI Index
   Hansard Extracts
  DOCUMENTS
  AUDIO FILES
  BOATS DATABASE
  SIEVX PASSENGERS
  MAILING LIST
   Archives
  OTHER SIEVX SITES
  PARLIAMENT
  RESTRICTED AREA
  CONTACT ME
 
Search with Google
Search sievx.com
MEDIA

GOVERNMENT

 
 
Ali Mehdi Sobie & Hazam Al Rowaimi lost their entire families on SIEVX
 

'...wherever you look you see the dead children like birds floating on the water...'

Read transcript

'on a sinking boat a woman gave birth off the coast of Java while the Christmas card I gave to my love celebrated the birth of another'

Play song

146 children ~ 142 women ~ 65 men

Now Labor Can Get to the Truth
Is There A Connection Between Australia's People Smuggling Disruption Program & the Sinking of SIEVX?
by Marg Hutton
1 January 2008

2008 is an auspicious year for those who are concerned about the unanswered questions surrounding the sinking of SIEVX. With a new Labor Government, Senator John Faulkner as Special Minister of State and the return of Jacinta Collins to the Senate mid year, the time is ripe for action on SIEVX. In Opposition, Faulkner & Collins were responsible for many of the probing questions put to the Howard Government and its agencies concerning the people smuggling disruption program operating in Indonesia and the sinking of SIEVX and both have spoken out on the need for a judicial inquiry into these matters.

In October 2001 353 asylum seekers drowned trying to get to Australia in an area of ocean that was patrolled daily by Australian border protection surveillance aircraft. Those who lost their lives were mostly women and children, many of whom were desperate to reunite with husbands and fathers already here.

There has been no official inquiry into this horrific tragedy other than the limited examination by the Senate Select Committee on A Certain Maritime Incident (CMI). The Howard Government took no action on the first recommendation of the CMI Report for a judicial inquiry into people smuggling disruption activities undertaken in Indonesia by Australian and Indonesian police. It also ignored the subsequent Senate motions which specifically called for a broad ranging judicial inquiry into disruption activities and the sinking of SIEVX. (1, 2, 3)

The lack of a comprehensive inquiry has allowed for the proliferation of theories that go well beyond the evidence – that the Australian Navy watched people drowning in the water but failed to rescue them or that the boat was deliberately sabotaged. The sinking of SIEVX will always remain clouded in suspicion with the truth lost in a fog of myth, contested claims, obfuscation and denial unless and until there is a full powers independent judicial inquiry into this matter.

With the election of the Labor government five weeks ago, the SIEVX tragedy can finally get the attention it warrants.

In Opposition, the ALP repeatedly expressed its anger and frustration with the Howard Government's inaction, moving a Senate motion criticising inconsistencies in government evidence to the CMI Committee and calling for a full powers judicial inquiry into the peoples smuggling disruption program and the sinking of SIEVX and supporting Greens and Democrats Senate motions on the subject.

The late Labor Senator Peter Cook, chair of the CMI Committee, spoke out in Parliament about inconsistencies in the evidence provided to the CMI Committee when a key document concerning the sinking of SIEVX - the DFAT cable of 23 October 2001 - was provided to the Senate seven months after it was requested and four months after the CMI Report was published.

Labor Senator Jacinta Collins vigorously questioned the authorities concerning SIEVX over several years and referred to SIEVX twice in her valedictory speech to the Senate in 2005, identifying it as the issue which had most effected her emotionally as a Senator.

Senator Faulkner tenaciously pursued the Australian Federal police and other agencies in the CMI Committee and later in Senate Estimates concerning the people smuggling disruption program and vividly expressed Labor's concerns in the climax to a series of three adjournment speeches to parliament in September 2002:

 
This is the deeply concerning aspect of disruption. How far has it gone? What activities are acceptable; what are not? Who carries them out? Who pays for them? What accountability and control mechanisms are in place? Who authorises these activities? What is the effect of these activities? What, if any, consideration was given to questions of the safety of lives at sea? ...

And what about the vessel now known as SIEVX, part of the people-smuggling operation of the notorious people smuggler Abu Quassey? That vessel set sail on 18 October 2001 and sank on 19 October 2001, drowning 353 people, including 142 women and 146 children. Were disruption activities directed against Abu Quassey? Did these involve SIEVX?

I intend to keep asking questions until I find out. And, Mr Acting Deputy President, I intend to keep pressing for an independent judicial inquiry into these very serious matters.

At no stage do I want to break, nor will I break, the protocols in relation to operational matters involving ASIS or the AFP.

But, those protocols were not meant as a direct or an indirect licence to kill.

Australia has a moral obligation to address these unresolved questions swirling around SIEVX and the people smuggling disruption program - for the grieving survivors and relatives of victims and for people of conscience who are concerned that Australia may hold some responsibility for the tragedy.

With Labor in power it now has the opportunity to clear the fog and reveal the truth by establishing the full powers independent judicial inquiry that that it has so long called for.

A letter to your local federal member of Parliament will let the Rudd Government know that the electorate is looking to it to finally clear the air on SIEVX.

 


 

 
CAN YOU HELP?

Indonesian to English translations needed
(Two years ago SIEVX.com discovered a collection of Indonesian articles from Gatra magazine and other Indonesian media published in 2001 concerned with the arrest of Abu Quassey and Brigadier Agus Safuan and other SIEVX-related matters. We would be grateful for any assistance that could be provided to translate these articles into English. If you are able to translate one or more of these articles please contact us. Thanks to everyone who has helped with this project so far...)

last updated 1 January 2008

NEWS

Senate blocks inquiry into asylum seeker tragedy ~ 15 October, Greens

Australia mulls extradition of smuggler ~ 11 July, Antara

Smuggler Arrested ~ 10 July, Tempo

Let's not forget the SIEV-X ~ 16 June, Online Opinion

No visa for people smuggler ~ 8 Feb, SMH

People smuggler... decent man ~ 4 Feb, SMH

Top cop, bad times ~ 2 Feb, SMH

It's a little thing that's called citizenship ~ 26 Jan, Age

People smuggler blocks to continue ~ 17 Jan, Age

AFP bid to block asylum evidence ~ 15 Dec, SMH

Memorial is also hope for humanity ~ 30 Aug, SMH

Asylum seekers lost at sea not forgotten ~ 30 Aug, CT

Police urged to release names ~ 30 Aug, AAP

Boat victims remembered... ~ 22 July, CT

PM's Credentials Sink ~ 22 July, Age

Exploiting the military for political gain ~ 22 July, Age

Morale Overboard ~ 22 July, Age

Revealed: How Howard's plan threatened security ~ 22 July, Age

Telling them what they don't want to know ~ 14 June, Aus

Refugee advocate praises Indon deal ~ 4 May, Age

ALP bid to avoid another Tampa crisis ~ 28 Feb, Aus
(The Australian understands their boat has been dubbed SIEV XX - or "suspected illegal entry vessel XX" - by the Government. SIEV X is commonly used to refer to the Indonesian fishing boat that sank en route to Christmas Island in October 2001, killing 353 people, on the eve of the election and sparking the "children overboard" affair [sic].)

Keith Windschuttle on SIEVX ~ Jan 2007, Quadrant
(The worst Australian atrocity story of the present period is the fate of SIEV-X, or Suspected Illegal Entry Vessel, Unknown. This issue remains deeply embedded within the cultural grievances of our tertiary-educated, middle-class Left...)

5th ANNIVERSARY

Sad facts... ~ 21 Oct (Aus)
Zealots hijack tragedy ~ 20 Oct (DT)
Tony Burke ~ 19 Oct (Doorstop)
Incident to enter classrooms ~ 19 Oct (World Today)
SIEVX Kit ~ 19 Oct (Aus)
A reminder of how we treat people... ~ 19 Oct (Age)
Andrew Bartlett ~ 19 Oct (Media Release)
Senate Extract ~ 19 Oct
Senate Extract ~ 18 Oct
Senate Extract ~ 17 Oct
Mohammad Al Ghazzi ~ 16 Oct
No New Conspiracy ~ 16 Oct (Aus)
Kim Beazley ~ 16 Oct (Doorstop)
Tragedy Marked ~ 16 Oct (Aus)
Tears Fall ~ 16 Oct (CT)
Memorial service to remember ~ 15 Oct (ABC)
Memorial Years away ~ 15 Oct (SMH)
Trauma Recalled ~ 15 Oct (CT)
Memorial plans thwarted ~ 14 Oct (AM)
Organisers slam ban ~ 14 Oct (Age)
Memorial will shine ~ 14 Oct (SMH)
Row over memorial ~ 13 Oct (Age)
Memorial plans stall ~ 8 Oct (ABC)
Christine Milne ~ 7 Oct (Media Release)

HANSARD & QoNs
AFP & Customs
DIMA
Ellison ~ Dec
Ellison ~ May
Ellison ~ Feb
Campbell ~ Feb
Milne ~ Feb
Milne ~ Dec
Milne ~ Dec
Milne ~ Dec
Previous Q&As

WEBSITE COMMENT
Now Labor can get to the truth
On the 5th anniversary
No Happy Ending
And the Lies... continue
Year Five...
Keelty Seeks Shelter...
Congratulations Mia Dyson
Ellison Replies
ADA Director Speaks Out...
We Remember SIEVX
Uncommon Discourtesy
Sinking Position 'Unknown'
Daoed: Cop Speaks
Farewell Jacinta!
The 45th Survivor
Daoed Trial: Week 1
Hidden in plain view
Unfinished Business
Out In 4 Years
Not Forgotten
Vanstone Blunders

Previous Comment
RSS 2.0 XML file (0.91 compatible)

MENTIONS
Stephen Bartos ~ Dec 2007

 
 
 
 http://sievx.com/index.shtml ( 394523) | ©Copyright Marg Hutton ~ sievx.com / siev-x.com 2002-2008